22:4622:46, 14 October 2023diffhist+173
Crazy, Stupid, Love
If
WP:COMMONNAME] can be clearly established then maybe that justifies precedence in some cases. In most cases you are just making a worse encyclopedia for readers. For fairness and clarity we have footnotes. Undid revision 1180080745 by
Wasabi OS (
talk)Tags: UndoReverted
04:4304:43, 14 October 2023diffhist−153
Slow Horses
This television series has one name. Listing the names of the various books as "alt names" is not construtive.
03:5703:57, 14 October 2023diffhist−9
Moneyball (film)
WP:SDEXAMPLES YEAR film by DIRECTOR eg "2017 film by Jordan Peele". Keep short description short. Unless nationality is particularly important to disambiguate this from similar titles, there is no need for it in the short description.
03:4003:40, 14 October 2023diffhist−114
The King of Staten Island
WP:FILMLEAD and
WP:SYNTH A mere two reviews in the Critical response section are not enough to make such expansive claims as if they are fair generalizations. The lead is supposed to summarize not supplant what is actually in the article body.
03:3503:35, 14 October 2023diffhist+38
He's All That
See talk page. Editor claimed that the reviews in the Critical response section had an WP:UNDUE emphasis on the positive despite being negative overall. Section still needs more negative reviews.
03:2703:27, 14 October 2023diffhist+12
The Usual Suspects
While there are many Indian films that contain some similar plot points as American films the claim that this a remake or an adaptation is highly dubious. Please discuss on talk page.
02:5002:50, 14 October 2023diffhist−18
The Usual Suspects
Manual revert of unexplained changes. See Revision as of 15:08, 9 December 2022 (edit) (undo) 2405:201:f01b:b017:7856:2328:7361:4b19
WP:FILMCAST "All names should be referred to as credited" Keyser Söze is not in the credits.
02:1202:12, 14 October 2023diffhist+54
Chicago Fire (TV series)
Add warning comment. DO NOT UPDATE RANK. The point of this plot section is to introduce the characters at the start of the series. His season 10 rank is not relevant yet.
22:4622:46, 14 October 2023diffhist+173
Crazy, Stupid, Love
If
WP:COMMONNAME] can be clearly established then maybe that justifies precedence in some cases. In most cases you are just making a worse encyclopedia for readers. For fairness and clarity we have footnotes. Undid revision 1180080745 by
Wasabi OS (
talk)Tags: UndoReverted
04:4304:43, 14 October 2023diffhist−153
Slow Horses
This television series has one name. Listing the names of the various books as "alt names" is not construtive.
03:5703:57, 14 October 2023diffhist−9
Moneyball (film)
WP:SDEXAMPLES YEAR film by DIRECTOR eg "2017 film by Jordan Peele". Keep short description short. Unless nationality is particularly important to disambiguate this from similar titles, there is no need for it in the short description.
03:4003:40, 14 October 2023diffhist−114
The King of Staten Island
WP:FILMLEAD and
WP:SYNTH A mere two reviews in the Critical response section are not enough to make such expansive claims as if they are fair generalizations. The lead is supposed to summarize not supplant what is actually in the article body.
03:3503:35, 14 October 2023diffhist+38
He's All That
See talk page. Editor claimed that the reviews in the Critical response section had an WP:UNDUE emphasis on the positive despite being negative overall. Section still needs more negative reviews.
03:2703:27, 14 October 2023diffhist+12
The Usual Suspects
While there are many Indian films that contain some similar plot points as American films the claim that this a remake or an adaptation is highly dubious. Please discuss on talk page.
02:5002:50, 14 October 2023diffhist−18
The Usual Suspects
Manual revert of unexplained changes. See Revision as of 15:08, 9 December 2022 (edit) (undo) 2405:201:f01b:b017:7856:2328:7361:4b19
WP:FILMCAST "All names should be referred to as credited" Keyser Söze is not in the credits.
02:1202:12, 14 October 2023diffhist+54
Chicago Fire (TV series)
Add warning comment. DO NOT UPDATE RANK. The point of this plot section is to introduce the characters at the start of the series. His season 10 rank is not relevant yet.