In a 2003 bibliography of the era, Jon Smele summarized the book as, "masterfully written" and "the only full-length, scholarly, non-partisan account of the genesis, course and repression of the rebellion to have appeared in English."[1]
Hanak, Harry (1971). "Review of The Russian Revolution: The Origin, Phases and Meaning of the Bolshevik Victory., ; The Russian Search for Peace: February-October 1917., ; Kronstadt 1921., ; 1919: Red Mirage". International Affairs. 47 (4): 779–782.
doi:
10.2307/2625690.
ISSN0020-5850.
JSTOR2625690.
In a 2003 bibliography of the era, Jon Smele summarized the book as, "masterfully written" and "the only full-length, scholarly, non-partisan account of the genesis, course and repression of the rebellion to have appeared in English."[1]
Hanak, Harry (1971). "Review of The Russian Revolution: The Origin, Phases and Meaning of the Bolshevik Victory., ; The Russian Search for Peace: February-October 1917., ; Kronstadt 1921., ; 1919: Red Mirage". International Affairs. 47 (4): 779–782.
doi:
10.2307/2625690.
ISSN0020-5850.
JSTOR2625690.