Categories | ||||
|
This is a conversation continued from Wikipedia:Categories for deletion/Log/2006 April 29 from where the following is copied:
I don't have anything further to add, other than I would support a renaming of the category, but can't think of anything that really works. Carcharoth 07:50, 6 May 2006 (UTC)
I agree they don't seem all that dissimilar maybe you could merge them all into one file like you suggested by naming a file, Category:Categories by geographical location. The only problem i see by doing so is if you were to make a category like that it could be too dense it could encompass so many things. So i think possibly condense your idea slightly to make it more specific which is what i think the original catagories were trying to accomplish. However it may also just be best to let sleeping dogs lie, if making a larger category filled with those 3 categories together ( Category:Categories by city, Category:Categories by country and Category:Categories by region) makes it too large, unspecific or confusing then maybe it should just be left as it is. However i do agree there should be some change.
Categories | ||||
|
This is a conversation continued from Wikipedia:Categories for deletion/Log/2006 April 29 from where the following is copied:
I don't have anything further to add, other than I would support a renaming of the category, but can't think of anything that really works. Carcharoth 07:50, 6 May 2006 (UTC)
I agree they don't seem all that dissimilar maybe you could merge them all into one file like you suggested by naming a file, Category:Categories by geographical location. The only problem i see by doing so is if you were to make a category like that it could be too dense it could encompass so many things. So i think possibly condense your idea slightly to make it more specific which is what i think the original catagories were trying to accomplish. However it may also just be best to let sleeping dogs lie, if making a larger category filled with those 3 categories together ( Category:Categories by city, Category:Categories by country and Category:Categories by region) makes it too large, unspecific or confusing then maybe it should just be left as it is. However i do agree there should be some change.