Harvard end
Huntington Hardwick was the only player who was unanimously selected as a first-team All-American by all 27 selectors identified below. Other players selected as a first-team All-American by a majority of the selectors were Harvard halfback
Eddie Mahan (26 selections), Harvard guard
Stan Pennock (26 selections), Princeton tackle
Harold Ballin (22 selections), Michigan halfback
John Maulbetsch (20 selections), Cornell quarterback
Charley Barrett (19 selections), and Dartmouth guard
Clarence Spears (16 selections). The Los Angeles Times reported that "
Maulbetsch, Michigan's hero, is about the only one of 1914's stars who received an almost unanimous vote."[2]
The chart below reflects the number of polls in which the leading candidates (any player with at least two first-team All-American designations) were selected as first-team All-Americans.
^"All-America Addendum"(PDF). College Football Historical Society Newsletter. May 2006. Archived from
the original(PDF) on June 13, 2010. Retrieved March 5, 2010.
^"Eckersall Names All-Stars: Eckersall Names One Western Man; Maulbetsch of Michigan on All-American". Waterloo Evening Courier. December 7, 1914.
^Monty (November 28, 1914). "Another All-American Team: EICHENLAUB IS PLACED ON SECOND ELEVEN; "Monty" Selects Mythical Eleven for Daily News Readers—Gives His Reasons". The Fort Wayne Daily News.
^
ab"JAMES P. SINNOT PUTS TOOHEY ON HIS ALL-AMERICAN ELEVEN". New Brunswick Times. December 1, 1914.
^"Herbert Reed, Mack Whalen And The Newark News Selected Toohey On Their All-American Eastern Team". New Brunswick Times. December 7, 1914.
Harvard end
Huntington Hardwick was the only player who was unanimously selected as a first-team All-American by all 27 selectors identified below. Other players selected as a first-team All-American by a majority of the selectors were Harvard halfback
Eddie Mahan (26 selections), Harvard guard
Stan Pennock (26 selections), Princeton tackle
Harold Ballin (22 selections), Michigan halfback
John Maulbetsch (20 selections), Cornell quarterback
Charley Barrett (19 selections), and Dartmouth guard
Clarence Spears (16 selections). The Los Angeles Times reported that "
Maulbetsch, Michigan's hero, is about the only one of 1914's stars who received an almost unanimous vote."[2]
The chart below reflects the number of polls in which the leading candidates (any player with at least two first-team All-American designations) were selected as first-team All-Americans.
^"All-America Addendum"(PDF). College Football Historical Society Newsletter. May 2006. Archived from
the original(PDF) on June 13, 2010. Retrieved March 5, 2010.
^"Eckersall Names All-Stars: Eckersall Names One Western Man; Maulbetsch of Michigan on All-American". Waterloo Evening Courier. December 7, 1914.
^Monty (November 28, 1914). "Another All-American Team: EICHENLAUB IS PLACED ON SECOND ELEVEN; "Monty" Selects Mythical Eleven for Daily News Readers—Gives His Reasons". The Fort Wayne Daily News.
^
ab"JAMES P. SINNOT PUTS TOOHEY ON HIS ALL-AMERICAN ELEVEN". New Brunswick Times. December 1, 1914.
^"Herbert Reed, Mack Whalen And The Newark News Selected Toohey On Their All-American Eastern Team". New Brunswick Times. December 7, 1914.